Geothermal Heat Pros and Cons

July 25, 2017 , In: Home Improvement, Indoors , With: No Comments

We’ve come to the end of Your Wild Home’s series on energy sources. If you’re just jumping in, make sure to check out the articles on CoalOilGasSolar, and Wind too! Let me know what you think of the series in the comments below!

When you discover the vast benefits of geothermal energy, you’ll immediately want to fast-forward to a future version of yourself. Comfortably settled in your forever home on lots of land, flush with cash. Unless, of course, you’re already there.

Geothermal home heating utilizes a simple pump and pipe setup to pull clean energy directly from the Earth’s core straight into your home. Sound too good to be true? Wondering if there’s a hidden catch? You be the judge.

geothermal energy

Geothermal Energy Pros

There are many pluses to geothermal energy that may tip your scale in its favor.

  • Efficient

Geo-exchange systems tap into and transfer already-existing in-ground energy. Regardless of your home’s geographic location, underground temperatures remain relatively stable, approximately 50 degrees Fahrenheit year round. Because geothermal pumps automatically source air at this median temperature from the get-go, additional energy necessary to warm or cool your home as desired remains minimal.

Consistency of underground temperatures also help maintain home humidity levels. Geothermal heat pumps naturally preserve a humidity level of 50 percent. This can be especially cost-effective if you live in a humid area.

  • Sustainable

You can’t really find a more steady source of energy than the ever-present heat of our planet’s core. In fact, friction form Earth’s formation billions of years ago continues to accumulate. Iron-rich and radioactive elements naturally present in the core additionally produce heat as they rise to the surface.

On a global scale, it is believed the energy in our planet will continue to last billions of years. On a personal level, it’s a pretty safe bet your geo-exchange system will enjoy a lifetime of uninterrupted renewable resource use.

  • Simple

Geothermal heat systems can be installed in newly constructed as well as already existing homes. The system itself is universally simple, possessing only three distinct components. Ground piping and the pump itself necessarily require purchase and installation. If you are switching out systems in a current structure, though, pre-existing air delivery ducts can often be reutilized.

  • Low Maintenance

Simplicity is one factor that earns geo-exchange the bragging right of low maintenance. Each system utilizes three elements, but only one — the pump — has moving parts. Pumps stand above ground, so they’re easily accessible for repair.

All three components remain protected from outdoor elements. Many system manufacturers award warranties of up to 50 years.

  • Quiet

Not to be underestimated, the amount of habitual background noise in our home matters. Sometimes levels are only discernible when an appliance actually stops, which only adds strength to the original argument.

Geothermal systems do not utilize famously humming outdoor condensing units. The indoor air compressor, or pump, normally emits a buzz frequency equal to that of a refrigerator. Pumps are generally in a basement or storage space, separate from common living areas.

  • Cost Cutting

Here’s the kicker: Thanks to its efficient utilization of pre-existing energy, geothermal heat can immediately save you money. How much? Between 20-50 percent on cooling and 30-60 percent on heating costs.

This doesn’t even account for additional rebates and tax incentives for system purchase and installation.

geothermal energy plant

Geothermal Energy Cons

Geothermal sounds like a great option — so what are you waiting for? The cons of course. There’s always a flip side.

  • Expensive

If you’re prone to sticker shock, maybe it’s best to start with percentage data. For new home construction, geo-exchange system purchase price can run 40 percent more than traditional air exchange systems. Underground pipe placement requires additional financing and depends on many factors, including property configuration and drill accessibility.

In an already-existing home, you can recycle ductwork, but it may need modification. Geothermal heat replacement in a traditional 2,000-square-foot home costs $10,000-$20,000 according to most estimates.

  • Specialized

In direct opposition to the simplicity of its design, installation of a geothermal heat system requires distinct specialization. Land drilling and excavation are tasks best left to professionals. Because residential geothermal energy is a relatively new field, few home installers possess apt experience. Given the law of supply and demand, chances are good that those who do will charge handsomely for their service.

  • Environmentally Disruptive

Any time a company excavates and drills land, it disturbs our ecosystem. Geothermal energy pipework varies in size and scope based on individual usage, but even the least intrusive options require excessive digging.

Homes on narrow lots utilize pipes that run in vertical loops, necessitating drill depths of up to 400 feet. Homeowners with more land often choose the less expensive excavation option of placing horizontal pipes in underground trenches. However, even this alternative requires a dig depth of 6 feet.

The choice of an underground energy source pays its toll to the provider.

This brings us back to the vision of yourself as a cash-ready, long-term homeowner on ample acreage. Geothermal heat pays for itself over time with minimal maintenance and unlimited future availability. Perhaps the only remaining question is simply that of your timing.

Newsletter Blog Sign Up

The following two tabs change content below.


Editor at Your Wild Home
Hey! I'm Megan. I am a dog-lover and enjoy exploring the outdoors. Your Wild Home covers a lot of topics, including (but not limited to) home improvement, home decor, construction, real estate, and sustainability. I enjoy writing in third-person and I am addicted to chocolate, coffee, and terrible puns. Learn more on my About Me page!
Geothermal Heat Pros and Cons
Article Name
Geothermal Heat Pros and Cons
Geothermal heat and energy is still new to the home energy scene, so there's a lot for homeowners to learn! Here are the pros and cons.
Publisher Name
Your Wild Home
Publisher Logo
There are no comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


One of my personal mantras is “work smarter, not harder,” so most of Your Wild Home’s posts in this category center around simple ways you can inexpensively and quickly improve your home. I think it’s a common misconception that this kind of focus means you’re some kind of fanatic for efficiency or an extreme cost-cutter. In reality, I’m just lazy, so if something is going to cost me less (in the short or long term) and save me time, why the heck wouldn’t I do it?

As ~one of those~ crazy dog people, you’ll also find a few ideas on ways to accommodate for your pup at home. Whether you’re renting or own a home, there are plenty of ways that you can make Fido feel more at home so it reduces potential damage. Let’s be honest, those first few months of dog-ownership are mostly fortified by those puppy eyes. But those puppy eyes won’t get your security deposit back from your landlord or increase your home resale value. So being proactive is your best bet!

Everyone has a different style and budget, which makes providing universal home décor and home improvement advice largely impossible. What you’ll find on here is an assortment of advice that reveals how you can easily keep the inside of your home organized and running relatively smoothly. Best of all, none of these ideas will cost you a pretty penny.

Here are some of my favorites from the “Indoor” category:

I’m still getting a handle on the direction of Your Wild Home, and I’d love to hear from you if you’re a frequent reader! Want to learn more about something? Head over to my contact page to shoot me an idea!