YWH Gas Heat 2017

Gas Heat Pros and Cons

July 13, 2017 , In: Home Improvement, Indoors , With: No Comments

Hey there! If you’re just catching up, I’m doing a series on energy sources! I recently covered coal and oil. Coming up are solar, wind, and geothermal energy. Hope you enjoy… Make sure to comment and let me know what you think! 🙂

Once viewed as a mere consequence of drilling for oil, natural gas has fast become an energy source in its own right. In fact, natural gas has now passed oil and is nearly tied with electricity as the most used energy source in the U.S., according to the Energy Information Administration. As energy costs rise, it’s worth examining the pros and cons of gas heat.

This rise in use is due in part to the fact that it burns cleaner than other fossil fuels. It produces half the carbon dioxide of coal and nearly a third less than oil.

On top of this, gas used to heat a home is warmer than electric heat and has efficiency rates of up to 90 percent. It’s no wonder that, of the 83 million U.S. homes with access to natural gas, 84 percent use it, according to a survey from the EIA.

If it’s popular and it’s better for the environment, it seems like installing gas is an easy choice, but along with the rewards that come with natural gas, there are also risks — for both homeowners and the planet. Whether you’re considering changing from natural gas or to it, here’s what you should know to make an informed decision.

gas heat pros cons

What Is Natural Gas and Where Does It Come From?

Originally, the only accessible type of natural gas was a byproduct of oil drilling. It was found in underground pockets about 5,000 feet below the earth’s surface, usually just above oil. This type of gas is referred to as conventional gas because, for years, it’s been the simplest gas to reach and the easiest to profit from.

But there are other pockets of gas deeper in the earth, around 15,000 feet down, called unconventional gases. Shale gas is one of these, and, until now, shale gas was impossible to extract. Thanks to advances in technology, shale is fast becoming the go-to source for natural gas.

In many ways, this isn’t a bad thing. For instance, we supply nearly all the natural gas the U.S. consumes. So, reaching more sources of the gas beneath our feet lessens America’s dependence on foreign fuel.

The biggest problem with these new gas reserves lies in the way the removal. Hydraulic fracturing (fracking) gets deep into the earth and fractures the rocks that hold the gas. Unfortunately, this process is not as environmentally-friendly as the gas itself.

Fracking has been linked to contaminated drinking-water supplies in the areas in which its used. It has strained municipal water reserves because of the large amounts of water needed for the process itself.

Another environmental risk is that some methane, a potent greenhouse gas, leaks out during its extraction and transfer. Some argue that, over time, this leakage will cancel out most of the clean-burning benefits of natural gas. Whether that’s true remains to be seen.

For now, the low cost of gas and its smaller carbon footprint have improved energy efficiency and lessened CO2 emissions in the U.S. by replacing coal as the main way to produce electricity for the grid. Oddly enough, even if you do choose electric heat, you will most likely still be utilizing natural gas, just not directly in your home.

Pros and Cons of Natural Gas in Your Home

Here’s a list of pros and cons, unrelated to the environment, of using gas heat in your home.


  • Hotter heat: Gas heat temperatures range from 120-140 degrees Fahrenheit, while electric appliances are closer to 85-95 degrees Fahrenheit.
  • Highly efficient: Efficiency rates of natural gas are much higher than electric. They tend to be over 90 percent efficient.
  • Cleaner burning fireplace: Gas fuel means less mess and maintenance for your chimney than wood, yet you can still enjoy an open flame.
  • Can be used for both power generation and heat: Using micro combined heating and power, called MCHP units, gas becomes an even more efficient energy source.  
  • Easily accessible: With over 2.4 million miles of pipeline, most residents in the U.S. have an option for gas in their homes.
  • Less operating cost: Since gas fuel is cheaper than electricity, gas furnaces tend to cost less to operate.


  • Potential hazards: About 150 deaths in the U.S. per year are from carbon monoxide poisoning from gas leaks.  
  • Higher upfront costs: Gas furnaces tend to be more expensive to buy and install than electric furnaces.
  • Relatively short shelf life: Gas furnaces typically last half as long as comparable electric furnaces.
  • More upkeep: Gas furnaces require yearly maintenance from a professional to function best.


As you can see, choosing gas is not necessarily a clear-cut decision. Hopefully, this article has given you some insight to make the decision that’s right for you.

Newsletter Blog Sign Up

The following two tabs change content below.


Editor at Your Wild Home
Hey! I'm Megan. I am a dog-lover and enjoy exploring the outdoors. Your Wild Home covers a lot of topics, including (but not limited to) home improvement, home decor, construction, real estate, and sustainability. I enjoy writing in third-person and I am addicted to chocolate, coffee, and terrible puns. Learn more on my About Me page!
Gas Heat Pros and Cons
Article Name
Gas Heat Pros and Cons
Once viewed as a mere consequence of drilling for oil, natural gas has fast become an energy source in its own right. Here are the pros & cons of gas heat.
Publisher Name
Your Wild Home
Publisher Logo
There are no comments yet. Be the first to comment.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.